Weather Forecast


Health-care debate will continue after ruling

Email Sign up for Breaking News Alerts
News Worthington,Minnesota 56187
Daily Globe
Health-care debate will continue after ruling
Worthington Minnesota 300 11th Street / P.O. Box 639 56187

ST. PAUL -- A U.S. Supreme Court ruling is the law of the land. Until it isn't.

That is the message Republicans are spreading and Democrats dreading in light of Thursday's 5-4 decision to uphold a new federal health-care law.


Minutes after the ruling became public, both major parties distributed a frantic message: send money. Beyond that agreement, however, the federal law sharply divides Republicans and Democrats.

Republicans want to capitalize on the decision to get donations for their candidates, pledging to repeal what they call "Obamacare." Democrats said they need funds to keep their own in power and keep the Affordable Care Act in force.

"We will have to wait and see what the public decides," state Sen. David Hann, R-Eden Prairie, said about the Nov. 6 elections.

Human Services Commissioner Lucinda Jesson, a Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton appointee, held out hope that Republicans and Democrats can work together as the state implements the federal health law, much of which does not begin until 2014.

"There is common ground to be found here," Jesson said.

Overall, Minnesota reaction mirrored that from elsewhere in breaking along predictable party lines.

"Victory" is how DFL Chairman Ken Martin headlined his email to party members seeking contributions to protect the law.

Minutes later, Minnesota Republican leaders sent their own email for donations, with the simple message: "The Supreme Court has upheld Obamacare, and there's a lot of work for us to do in order to ensure that Obamacare is repealed."

Representatives of the organization that brought the lawsuit against the health law were disappointed.

"Based on the decision, the federal government can now regulate individuals simply for existing," said Mike Hickey, Minnesota National Federation of Independent Business director.

Key to the federal law, enacted two years ago, is a provision requiring most Americans to carry health insurance. But Hickey said many provisions will affect businesses, especially small firms.

The federal act, for instance, requires employers with more than the equivalent of 50 full-time workers to provide insurance or pay a $2,000 penalty per employee.

"It could be a disincentive to grow," Hickey said about businesses approaching 50 employees.

Calling the law "pretty sweeping," Hickey said most businesses have not seen much impact so far.

"There are all kinds of restrictions on health insurance," he said, and his organization thinks several provisions will add to business costs.

Jesson, however, said her figures show businesses will save money.

State Rep. Tom Huntley, DFL-Duluth, said the federal law has many benefits, "most notably for adults and children who currently cannot purchase insurance because they have a pre-existing condition. The Affordable Care Act fixes this policy, making it possible for all to purchase insurance to keep them and their families healthy."

Huntley, the state House's leading health care finance Democrat, said one of the impacts already has been allowing 32,000 young Minnesotans to remain on their parents' health insurance until they are 26 years old.

"For consumers purchasing insurance, they'll no longer have to worry about lifetime caps on coverage," Huntley said.

Democrats like Huntley trumpet health-care exchanges the federal law requires. Exchanges, mostly on line marketplaces, would allow Americans to save money by buying insurance in a competitive atmosphere.

Former presidential candidate Michele Bachmann, a conservative Republican Minnesota congresswoman, said the ruling "raises the stakes for the coming months."

"Now, the only way to save the country from Obamacare's budget-busting government takeover of health care is to completely repeal it," she said.

On CNN, Bachmann called the decision "a turning point in American history. We will never be the same again."

Bachmann, chairwoman of the House Tea Party Caucus, was in the courtroom as the opinion was read.

U.S. Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., said the law will help for years: "Countless Minnesotans for generations to come will no longer have to suffer the burden of worrying about getting health insurance."

U.S. Rep. Betty McCollum, D-Minn., said she was proud to vote for the law.

"It is now time for Republicans in Congress to end their vitriolic repeal campaign and work on effectively implementing this law to the benefit of the American people," McCollum said.

U.S. Rep. John Kline, R-Minn., was typical of Republicans, calling the ruling "a devastating blow."

He said the action means "there is no reasonable limit on federal power."

The issue was hot in southern Minnesota's congressional district.

"Southern Minnesota small business owners, seniors and families continue to speak out against Obamacare, which Congressman Tim Walz has championed," said Republican state Rep. Mike Parry, running in a primary election to face Democratic congressman Walz in southern Minnesota. "This legislation will drive up costs for hard-working Minnesotans."

Walz stopped short of a strong endorsement of the federal law in his own statement, and indicated it could change.

"Health care reform is a journey, not a destination," Walz said. "And as we move forward, I will continue to work closely with health care experts, small businesses and southern Minnesotans to ensure all Americans have access to the high-quality, low-cost care they deserve."

Davis works for Forum Communications Co., which owns the Daily Globe.

Don Davis
Don Davis has been the Forum Communications Minnesota Capitol Bureau chief since 2001, covering state government and politics for two dozen newspapers in the state. Don also blogs at Capital Chatter on Areavoices.