Weather Forecast


As others see it: Clarify police log openness

Mitchell (S.D.) Daily Republic

The South Dakota Legislature will soon consider clarifying a law that should have been more specific in the first place.

0 Talk about it

In 2004, the Legislature approved SB 60, which made it permissible for law enforcement agencies to release police log information. It was a good start, since South Dakota was behind the times in public openness and because people deserve to see what business the police are conducting.

The problem with the 2004 law is that it states the daily logs be released at the discretion of an agency. The bill that will come before the Legislature this year would clarify the wording to say police logs shall be released to the public.

It may not seem like much, but this is a big deal. Allowing law-enforcement agencies to use their own discretion on what the public sees could, in effect, mean that those public records will not see the light of day — or at least not in their entirety.

This issue came up in the Legislature last year, but it was, unfortunately, part of a bill that also would have made all police mug shots public. That didn’t go over so well, because many feel mug shots should not be public record.

We disagree with that, but for now, we’ll take our battles one at a time. ...

Of course, we’ll hear someone proclaim that the current system isn’t broken, and there’s no reason to tinker with it. But any record that is allowed to be seen by the public at the discretion of its originating agency isn’t truly open.