ST. PAUL -- Minnesotans confused by claims that the state is struggling economically only need to look outside the Twin Cities.
And they should look at November's election returns.
Koochiching County has one of the highest unemployment rates in Minnesota, at 6.9 percent. In 2012, it went for Democrat Barack Obama by 10 points. This year, Republican Donald Trump won the county by 20 points.
Republicans in Minnesota did better at the November ballot box than many had dared even dream. They increased the size of their majority in the Minnesota House, and -- in a surprise to many -- gained control of the state Senate.
Trump also did better than many thought he would. He came within 1.5 points of Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton in Minnesota, a state that hasn’t gone for a Republican for president since Richard Nixon in 1972.
In post-election analysis, Trump’s success has been partly attributed to an ability to tap into a rural, working class disaffection with the status quo.
"This is about the forgotten man and the forgotten woman that are being expected to carry the weight for everyone else," U.S. Rep. Tom Emmer, a Trump supporter, told MinnPost on election night. "They’re asking for someone to hear them. They want everybody to succeed, but not at the expense of their success."
For some Minnesotans, that news might come as a surprise. Taken as a whole, Minnesota’s economy looks pretty good: Unemployment is among the lowest in the U.S., at 4 percent, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Minnesota is in the top 10 among states for median household income (above $61,000) and the number of jobs has risen above pre-recession levels, according to the Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development.
That all sounds good. So why are some Minnesotans feeling, as Emmer said, forgotten?
About 60 percent of Minnesota’s population lives in the Twin Cities metro area, where, by most measures, things are going pretty well. Unemployment is low, at 3.3 percent. Average weekly wages are among the highest in the state, are about $1,120, according to the most recently available data (of course, the cost of living is higher, too), and poverty, at 10.7 percent, is below the state average of 11.5 percent.
Economists consider some level of unemployment -- between about 4.5 percent and 6 percent -- a natural consequence of people changing jobs and other normal economic factors. But in a handful of Minnesota counties, including Koochiching, Itasca and Clearwater in the north, and Cottonwood in the south, unemployment in September was above 6 percent.
Koochiching County, which borders Canada in the central part of the state, had among the highest unemployment rates of any county in the state, at 6.9 percent in September, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics -- just a bit lower than the county’s unemployment rate in 2009-2011, during the Great Recession.
There, jobs in manufacturing, trade, transportation and utilities, and education and health services make up the largest shares of the workforce, and several sectors, including education and health services, and manufacturing have lost jobs in the last decade, according to data from the Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development.
Koochiching isn’t the only county in the Iron Rage with higher unemployment than the state, on average: In a September snapshot, Itasca, St. Louis, Carlton, Aitkin and Cass also shared that distinction, though to a lesser degree.
The economic challenges facing residents of northern Minnesota are nothing new, said state demographer Susan Brower.
"There were a lot of jobs that were lost" in the recession, said Monica Haynes of the University of Minnesota-Duluth. "For a lot of industries, they’re only now getting back to the level that they were before the recession."
Some of the changes that have caused instability in the industry for decades -- globalization and technological change -- don’t appear to be going away anytime soon, causing fear of a more unstable future.
Haynes said that there is a sense that mining layoffs that numbered more than 1,000 last year, may have contributed to the economic frustration in the context of the election. Those jobs, often unionized, can pay $90,000 or so a year.
While there are high poverty areas across the state, some of the largest clusters of people living below the poverty level are also in northern Minnesota, according to 2014 Census data.
In Mahnomen County, home to part of the White Earth Indian Reservation, more than 25 percent of residents are living in poverty. In Beltrami County, which includes Bemidji and parts of the Red Lake Reservation, that number is above 20 percent.
Whether by coincidence or not, northern Minnesota -- long a Democratic-Farmer Labor stronghold -- is a part of the state where Trump did well, even managing to flip some counties, such as Beltrami, Itasca, Mahnomen and Koochiching. Trump even won more votes than Clinton in the Iron Range town of Hibbing, which hasn’t voted for a Republican since Herbert Hoover.
While there tends to be higher unemployment in northern Minnesota, wages are generally better there for those who do have jobs, at least among Iron Range counties, said Steve Hine, director of the Labor Market Information Office at DEED.
The opposite happens in southwestern Minnesota, where unemployment is generally lower, along with wages.
"While many counties in the (southwest) part of the state might have low unemployment, they also have jobs that don’t pay (as) well," Hine wrote. "Much of this is industry driven."
In Cottonwood County in 2016, average weekly wages were $681 in the second quarter, about the same as last year's annual average weekly wages.
That’s not the lowest in the state, but it was coupled with the highest unemployment in Minnesota in September, at 7.5 percent according to federal officials -- an increase from 5.4 percent at the same time last year.
More than a quarter of Cottonwood County’s workers are employed in manufacturing, while retail trade and wholesale trade make up the next biggest job sectors.
Between the second quarter of 2015 and 2016, the county lost more than 300 jobs across sectors, according to data from DEED. Gains in some areas didn’t offset the loss of more than 460 jobs in manufacturing between those periods.
Last December, a beef packing plant with 260 employees in Windom -- located in south-central Cottonwood County -- closed. The University of Minnesota Extension Service estimated the closure would affect 409 jobs, mostly in beef cattle production, wholesale trade, and truck transportation, for a net total of $14.1 million in labor income lost.
In February, Glen Taylor announced he would buy the plant, which is slated to open by January.
Unlike the Range, Cottonwood County has tended to go for Republicans in presidential elections. In 2012, Mitt Romney carried the county with 57 percent of the vote, while Trump got 65 percent in this year’s election.
Kaul reports for MinnPost.com, a Twin Cities-based online newspaper.