SUBSCRIBE NOW AND SAVE 3 months just 99 ¢/month



Evasive carp avoid the nets again on Lake Okabena

Commercial fisherman Scott Deslauriers pulled an estimated 8,000 pounds of buffalo fish and 800 pounds of common carp from the lake Dec. 2.

120221 N DG Carp seining crew Lake Okabena S1.jpg
Scott Deslauriers (front left) and his crew transferred their catch to a storage net after the first pull on Lake Okabena Thursday afternoon. Tim Middagh / The Globe

WORTHINGTON — Southwest Minnesota’s commercial fisherman returned to Nobles County last Thursday, two weeks after his crew harvested 20,000 pounds of buffalo fish from Lake Bella , south of Worthington.

The crew, led by Scott Deslauriers, planned to spend Thursday through Saturday on Lake Okabena, pulling their nets through the Worthington lake in hopes of harvesting additional buffalo fish, as well as sediment-stirring common carp.

Unfortunately, a small haul on Thursday, combined with a Friday morning sonar search that showed a lack of schooling fish — and a weather forecast for wind and colder temperatures over the weekend — led the fishermen to pack up their equipment and head for home.


Deslauriers captured an estimated 8,000 pounds of buffalo fish and 800 pounds of common carp during Thursday’s seining effort.

Working with the Okabena-Ocheda Watershed District to reduce common carp from Lake Okabena, this was Deslauriers’ second attempt to sein rough fish this year. On Feb. 25, Deslauriers removed roughly 4,000 pounds of buffalo fish and 600 pounds of carp from the Worthington lake.

Finding the carp

Seining carp from Lake Okabena is nothing new. Okabena-Ocheda Watershed District Administrator Dan Livdahl has records that date back to 1926, when 529,754 pounds of roughfish were harvested from the local lake. Seining wasn’t done again until 1944, with four events that decade.

In the 1950s, seining in Lake Okabena was done every year, with the largest haul completed in 1957. That effort resulted in 74,593 pounds of buffalo fish and 44,202 pounds of carp being removed from the lake. Seining occurred twice in the 1980s and three times in the 1990s, but prior to February, the last seining effort on Lake Okabena was in 2006, when the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources harvested 7,430 pounds of carp.

The watershed district is focused on removing common carp from Lake Okabena as a way of improving water quality and clarity. Carp stir up sediment on the lake bottom and destroy vegetation. Studies in recent years by Wenck Associates have determined the lake is home to an abundance of the roughfish.

As a result, the watershed district has funded several efforts to track carp habits in the lake. Twice, Wenck biologists surgically implanted a dozen or more common carp with radio frequency devices that made it possible for Livdahl to monitor where the fish spawned in the springtime and where they tended to congregate. In addition, less invasive PIT tags were also implanted in nearly 200 Lake Okabena carp by Wenck biologists.

“The purpose of the tagging was two-fold,” Livdahl said.

Their first goal was to figure out where the carp went during the spawning season.


“I think we accomplished that — 70% to 80% of them were in Sunset Bay, so that seems to be where they’re spawning,” he said. “When the water was warm enough, we know they liked the shallowest areas of Sunset Bay, so I think we need to do something with Sunset Bay.”

The second goal was to find schools of carp by creating some Judas fish.

“Each radio-tagged fish represents a larger number of untagged fish in the school,” Livdahl said. “If we could scan the fish that were caught and compare those to the tagged carp, we’d have a good idea of the amount of carp in the lake.”

The difficulty came in actually trying to sein where large numbers of the tagged carp were known to be.

“Last winter when Scott seined, I thought there were a lot of tagged fish in that area, and somehow they got out,” Livdahl said.

What’s next?

“I think we’ve accomplished what we can with the radio-tagged fish,” Livdahl said, adding that the battery-operated radio frequency tags surgically implanted in carp in 2019 and 2020 are also at the end of their battery life.

The data gathered from the two tagging events will be useful going forward. The watershed district learned where the common carp prefer to spawn, and where they tend to be during the rest of the year.

What the district hasn’t learned is the quantity of carp they are dealing with in the lake.


While the February haul yielded no previously-tagged carp, the district decided not to have Wenck’s biologists return to Worthington to scan the roughfish captured by Deslauriers last week. Based on the small number of carp pulled in, it was cost-prohibitive.

“Last winter we had basically the same number of fish caught. We paid the consultant to come down and scan the fish … and it cost us $3,000 to do that,” Livdahl said. “We decided if we had a lot more fish, we would have definitely done it.”

With three different population density numbers for common carp in Lake Okabena — all of which seem high to the watershed district’s board of managers — Livdahl said the group planned to discuss during its 4 p.m. meeting Tuesday the potential for another winter-time seining.

“I think we still need to try to do a removal through seining in order to know what the carp population is in the lake,” Livdahl said. “By seining, you have to remove half or more of the carp from the lake every year in order to make any progress on lowering the carp population in the lake. You have to know what the population is. Removing 1,000 pounds isn’t going to do any good if you need to remove 100,000 pounds.”

120221 N DG Carp seining crew Lake Okabena S2.jpg
Southwest Minnesota's commercial fisherman, Scott Deslauriers, untangles a buffalo fish from the net on Lake Okabena Thursday afternoon. Tim Middagh / The Globe

120221 N DG Carp seining crew Lake Okabena S2.jpg
Southwest Minnesota's commercial fisherman, Scott Deslauriers, untangles a buffalo fish from the net on Lake Okabena Thursday afternoon. Tim Middagh / The Globe

Related Topics: FISH
What to read next
Topics include capturing value from nutrients in manure and regulations for selling manure.
Participants should want to improve health in their community by effectively communicating with policymakers, and be committed to racial equity and social justice in rural Minnesota.
A juvenile bald eagle was brought to an animal rehabilitation center in La Crosse, Wisconsin after being hit more than 80 miles away.
Glessing is a lifelong member of the Minnesota Farm Bureau.