Column: From a common ground to a great divide

WASHINGTON -- "We're not going to agree on every single issue," President Obama told the nation's governors at a black-tie dinner Sunday night, but "I'm confident that we're going to be able to find more and more common ground going forward."...

WASHINGTON -- "We're not going to agree on every single issue," President Obama told the nation's governors at a black-tie dinner Sunday night, but "I'm confident that we're going to be able to find more and more common ground going forward."

The members of the National Governors Association returned to the White House Monday morning for a working session with Obama. "The thing that connects all of us," the president reminded them, "is that we know what it means to govern ... and hopefully to forge some common ground."

An hour after leaving the White House, Republican governors told Obama what he could do with his common ground.

"President Obama is clearly the most liberal president we've had," Gov. Bobby Jindal of Louisiana proclaimed, at a news conference in the Mellon Auditorium arranged by the Republican Governors Association. "You'd literally have to go back to Jimmy Carter's years in the White House back in the 1970s to match the liberal ideology, to match the incompetence."

Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell proposed a remedy. "The president said three years ago that if he couldn't turn this around in three years, then this would be a one-term proposition. Well, Republican governors are deciding it's time to collect. It's time for a new president."


A third governor, Nikki Haley of South Carolina, piled on. "It was frustrating to see that he once again was finger-pointing at everyone else, and we don't have that luxury," she said, instructing the president: "Enough of the talk."

Not long ago, the annual winter meeting of the National Governors Association was a time of bipartisan camaraderie, a respite from politics to discuss "best practices" in the various laboratories of democracy. But now even this island of cooperation has been flooded by the partisan tsunami.

On the eve of this year's gathering, word came that Florida Gov. Rick Scott, a Republican, had dropped his state's membership in the NGA. Ohio dropped out last year, and Idaho the previous year. Texas Gov. Rick Perry quit years earlier.

The publication Governors Journal reported that "close to a dozen governors failed to show up" for this year's gathering, "or only attended partisan meetings" arranged by the RGA and Democratic Governors Association. The Democratic governors had their own, no-Republicans-allowed session with Obama, while the RGA held four fundraising-related events (two dinners, a lunch and a breakfast) over the weekend.

Among the missing: New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, a Democrat. Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer, a Republican, did show up, but she managed to use the annual gathering to further her grudge match with Obama. The two recently had a highly visible argument on an airport tarmac. This time, Brewer skipped the White House dinner, citing "other commitments."

At Monday morning's final NGA session, 18 of the governors' seats were empty. It's a shame so many cared so little about the gathering, because the NGA still has the potential to bridge ideological disagreements. At the final meeting, the governors moved so rapidly to adopt, unanimously, their various policies on economic development, natural resources, education and more that the NGA chairman, Gov. Dave Heineman, R-Neb., stalled for time. "I didn't anticipate we'd get done with this quite this quickly," he admitted.

At the White House, Obama made a rather strained effort to demonstrate his good fellowship with the governors; he identified Maryland's Gov. Martin O'Malley as "Jack O'Malley." But the friendliness, feigned or not, didn't last. Plans for a bipartisan news conference by governors in the White House driveway fell apart when reporters instead chased down individual governors leaving the executive mansion. At the botched news conference, the few reporters remaining had no questions for the NGA chairman and vice chairman.

From that chaotic scene the action shifted to the Mellon Auditorium, where Republican governors offered their thoughts on Obama.


McDonnell, dismissing the recent drop in unemployment ("it's a couple of months -- that doesn't make a trend"), accused the president of the "largest expansion of the federal government in American history" and demanded of Obama: "Don't make excuses. Don't finger-point. Lead."

Jindal summarized the complaint: "He has failed when it comes to his tax policy, his spending policy, his borrowing policy, his energy policy, his health policy." Jindal added that Obama is "governing from the extreme left" and has not run "a competent presidency," and "that's why you're going to see this administration be a one-term administration."

Otherwise, it sounds as if they had a productive meeting.

Dana Milbank's email address is .

What To Read Next
Get Local